Sign in

Order food

Order food

Bagel Jay's Bakery & Cafe

4.1 (643)$Bagel shop

2130 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216
•

Bagel Jay's Bakery & Cafe

2130 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216
•

Place order with

Toast
Ready in 30-35 min
No service fee
Toast Local
Ready in 30-35 min
No service fee
Grubhub
Ready in 15 min
$0.00 service fee
Seamless
Ready in 15 min
$0.00 service fee
Caviar
Ready in 18 min
No service fee
DoorDash
Ready in 18 min
No service fee
Menu
Oven Fresh
Single Bagel
$1.60
1/2 Dozen
$8.49
Baker's Dozen
$15.99
Bakers Dozen Sliced
$17.99
Sack Of Bagels & More
$20.99
Asiago
$2.39
Cinnamon Stick
$2.09
Cinnamon Stick W/ Butter
$2.59
Cinnamon Twist
$3.29
Sack Of Bagels & More Sliced
$22.99
Muffin
$2.99
Muffin W/ Butter
$4.59
1/2 Doz Muffins
$19.99
Doz Muffins
$29.99
Oatmeal
$2.19
Pastry Heart
$3.29
Challahs
$7.25
Day Old Bagels
$3.99
Bagel Crisps
$3.99
15 Bagel Special
$15.99
1/2 Doz Sliced
$9.49
SAC AND MORE FLAVOR UPCHARGE
$1.25
VEGGIE UPGRADE
$0.85
Asiago Upgrade
$0.80
Shmears
Bagel W/ Plain Cc
$3.49
Bagel W/ Flavored Shmear
$4.09
Bagel W/ Lox Shmear
$4.79
Bagel W/ Butter
$2.69
Bagel W/ Smart Balance
$2.69
Bagel W/ Jelly
$2.39
Bagel W/ PB & J
$3.69
Plain Shmear Tub
$3.69
Flavored Shmear Tub
$5.09
Lox Shmear Tub
$5.79
Shmear Of The Month Tub
$5.79
Butter Tub
$1.99
X Scoop Plain Cc
$2.50
X Scoop Flav Cc
$3.00
Coffee Upgrade
$0.50
Monday Madness
$5.49
Veggie Upgrade
$0.85
Asiago/ Wheat Bread Upgrade
$0.80
Breakfast Special
$5.79
Xtra Butter/Jelly
$0.60
BAGEL WITH JELLY
$2.39
Eggel Bagels
No. 1 Egg & Cheese
$3.99
No. 2 Egg, Ham & Cheese
$4.99
No. 3 Egg, Bacon & Cheese
$4.99
No. 4 Egg, Chicken Sausage & Cheese
$4.99
Xtra Cheese
$0.85
Xtra Meat
$0.85
Xtra Egg
$1.05
Egg Whites
$1.05
Asiago/ Wheat Bread Upgrade
$0.80
EGGEL ADD PL CR CHZ
$2.00
EGGEL ADD FLAVOR CR CHZ
$2.50
THE JAY NORMOUS
$9.99
VEGGIE UPGARADE
$0.85
Bagel With Egg
$2.65
Deli Favorites
Roasted Turkey Breast
$7.59
Ham & Cheese
$8.44
Ham
$7.59
Corned Beef
$9.99
Roast Beef
$8.99
BLT
$6.99
Turkey Melt
$8.44
Slice Of Cheese
$0.85
Xtra Meat
$6.00
Asiago/ Wheat Bread Upgrade
$0.80
1/2 Bagel/ Sand & Soup
$6.99
Chili Upgrade
$3.00
9.99 Special
$9.99
Lg Drink Upgrade
$0.20
VEGGIE UPGRADE
$0.85
ADD PLAIN CRM CHZ
$2.00
ADD FLAVOR CRM CHZ
$2.50
Jay's Classics
Tuna Salad
$7.59
Chicken Salad
$8.19
Egg Salad
$7.59
Cheese Melt
$3.99
Tuna Melt
$8.19
Cream Cheese & Nova
$12.99
Xtra Nova
$9.00
Veggie Delight
$5.69
Hummus
$6.99
Whitefish Salad
$9.99
Pizza Bagel
$5.99
Slice Of Cheese
$0.85
1/2 Bagel Sand & Soup
$6.99
Chili Upgrade
$3.00
Lg Drink Upgrade
$0.20
Asiago/ Wheat Bread Upgrade
$0.80
9.99 Special
$9.99
Terrific Tuesday Special
$7.99
CLASSIC SPECIAL WITH POP
$8.99
VEGGIE UPGRADE
$0.85
ADD PLAIN CRM CHZ
$2.00
ADD FLAVOR CRM CHZ
$2.50
Salads
Caesar Salad
$6.99
Chicken Caesar Salad
$9.49
Classic Salad Plate
$9.99
Greek Salad
$6.99
Green Salad
$9.49
Scoop Of Tuna
$6.00
Chicken On Salad
$6.00
SCOOP OF CHX SALAD
$6.00
SCOOP OF EGG SALAD
$5.00
Taste Tempting Specialties
Albuquerque Turkey
$9.49
Athens Chicken
$9.99
Athens Turkey
$9.49
Chicken Caesar Wrap
$9.99
Chicken Club Wrap
$9.99
Hummus Wrap Spectacular
$9.49
Mediterranean Tuna Spectacular
$9.49
The Buffalo Club
$9.49
The Delaware
$9.49
The Downtowner
$9.99
The Hertel
$9.99
The Hopkins
$10.99
The Reuben
$10.99
The Snyder
$9.49
Lg Drink Upgrade
$0.20
Asiago/ Wheat Bread Upgrade
$0.80
VEGGIE UPGRADE
$0.85
ADD PLAIN CRM CHZ
$2.00
ADD FLAVOR CRM CHZ
$2.50
XTRA CHEESE
$0.85
Soups & Sides
Soup Reg
$3.99
Soup Lg
$4.69
Chili Reg
$5.99
Chili Lg
$6.99
Chili W/Butter Bagel
$6.99
Chips
$1.75
Coleslaw Side
$2.19
Potato Salad
$2.19
1/2 Bagel & Soup
$6.99
Chili Upgrade
$3.00
Lg. Soup Upgrade
$3.00
Desserts
Cookie
$2.39
Black & White Cookie
$3.99
Brownie
$3.99
Crumb Cake
$3.39
Pound Cake
$3.99
Candy Bars
$1.00
Make it a Combo
Chips & Drink
$3.49
Side Salad & Drink
$3.99
Soup & Drink
$4.49
Lg Drink Upgrade
$0.20
Chili & Drink
$6.09
Lg Chili Upgrade
$3.00
Lg. Soup Upgrade
$3.00
Beverages
Jakees Java
$2.59
Hot Chocolate
$2.59
Cappuccino
$3.09
Hot Tea / Herbal Teas
$2.59
Milk
$1.99
Fountain Drink
$2.49
Iced Coffee
$3.39
Tropicana Juices & Lipton Teas
$3.79
Dr. Browns Gatorade SOBE
$3.79
Aquifina Water
$2.19
Java ToGo Box
$22.99
LG ICE COFFEE
$3.89
ADD SYRUP TO COFFEE
$0.60
Smoked Salmon & Bulk
4oz Smoked Salmon
$13.99
8oz Smoked Salmon
$24.99
Turkey /Lb
$12.99
Corned Beef /Lb
$16.99
Ham /Lb
$12.99
Roast Beef /Lb
$15.99
Tuna Salad /Lb
$16.99
Chicken Salad /Lb
$17.99
Egg Salad /Lb
$14.99
Whitefish Salad /Lb
$24.99
Hummus /Lb
$14.99
Coleslaw /Lb
$6.99
Potato Salad /Lb
$6.99
Plain Cream Cheese /Lb
$11.50
Flavored Cream Cheese /Lb
$14.00
Lox Cream Cheese /Lb
$15.00
Smoked Salmon /Lb
$39.99
Your order
Empty basket icon

Add something to your order.